Sunday, December 15, 2013

Strengthening Democracy


The results of the assembly polls held in December, 2013, in four states are as follows:

State/
Party
Total Seats/
Seats Obtained
Majority Seats Required/
Vote Share Obtained
Rajasthan200101
BJP16245%
Cong2133%
Others1622%
Delhi7036
BJP+3233%
AAP2830%
Cong825%
Others213%
Chattisgarh9046
BJP4941%
Cong3940%
Others219%
Madhya Pradesh230116
BJP16545%
Cong5836%
Others719%

Two observations:

[1] No party has obtained 51% of the vote share in any state.
[2] In Delhi, no party can form an effective government, given that it is difficult for BJP, AAP, and Cong to form a coalition government [going by statements made as this was written].

It is ideal and desirable that the ruling party has 51% of the vote share in a state and a hung assembly is made impossible.

Two amendments in the law are required to ensure this:

[1] The number of total seats in a state should be an odd number.
[2] If any single party does not have 51% of the vote share and 51% of the seats, then retaining the seats obtained by the top two ranking parties, the rest should be declared vacant, and a re-election should be conducted in respect of those seats, closing nomination for all except the top two parties.